Xena,
" . . . no one, can completely comprehend this religion with all of its peculiarities and it’s idiosyncrasies, in the way that only someone who has actually been an active Jehovah’s Witness can."
I must stand by this statement. The operative word here is, "completely". Surely any compassionate and intelligent individual who, although never been one of Jehovah’s’ Witnesses, could and should be able to empathize with the JW, or former JW, as it were. But not completely. That would be impossible. It’s not a snub, it’s just a matter on social mechanics. It is just as impossible for me, a white male, to completely understand what it must be like to be an African American. I’m intelligent (uh, somewhat anyway) and compassionate, but I could never claim to be able to completely understand their experience. That dose not impede my ability (or my responsibly) to join with others and to be effective in trying to understand my fellow man’s burden and make changes. But I’ll never know what his experience is like in its entirety. It isn’t that I should think my black friend feels elitist because he say’s than I can’t completely identify with him. Instead, I must respect and understand the limitations of the situation.
"Now, as an ex-JW, if you really believe that noone could truly understand, you are transferring that dynamic (elitism) to another place and noone could possibly understand where you have been and they are still outsiders. You then run the risk of being as dismissive with "outsiders" with that as the insensitive neverbeens might be to the plight of the ex-jw. "
I can’t speak for someone else, but for me at least, its not being an elitist to make the statement that someone who has never been a JW can’t completely understand what it’s like to have been one. I’m sorry if it may come off that way, but I wouldn’t be being completely honest with myself, to not recognize this reality. We may have to agree to disagree, agreeably, on this one. My wife who could pass any JW "test" due to her willingness and involvement to help former JW’s along with me with our little ministry (Life After The Watchtower) concedes her limitations to completely "get it".
I think maybe where we’re ‘missing’ each other, is that you may feel I’m diminishing you’re ability to ‘help’. No way! In fact someone who is ‘on the outside looking in’, very often has the more objective view than someone else who is too close. In that way, you and others who have never been ‘inside’ can be of great assistance to those who are hurting and need someone to help show them the way out. Most active Jehovah’s Witnesses won’t even listen to us former JW’s, because we have been so demonized by the Watchtower Society. I like to think of it as a team. Those of us who have come out of the cults with our experiences and those who haven’t been in, but have the skills and compassion, joining forces to help the hurting and the lost. Together we can make the difference.
Steve